Tuesday 23 October 2012

EWS STUDENTS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS A BOON FOR MIDDLE CLASS

It is general perception amongst middle class that EWS admission in unaided private schools are against the interest of fee paying middle class but really it is myth not reality. Inclusion of all class of society is not only beneficial for the social development of children but this inclusion is very helpful to protect from pinching pockets by unaided private school.various RTI information suggest that this EWS has reduced the monopoly of school lobby which was completely unregulated. In the name of privacy they were involved in mismanagement and parents had no option and ultimately they becomes victim of the greedy school management which was involved in all the non permissible activities like profiteering and fraud with the fee paying parents. submission of returns under rule 180 and audit of return remained a formality and DOE never cared about the interest of common citizen of the city.Delhi school education act and rules were regularly misinterpreted for the benefit of the greed of school lobby.
           In a recent RTI reply it has been revealed that a large no of schools had their entry level class pre school or pre primary but in the annual return they mentions class I as entry level class. It means that all the fee collected from the students in pre school or pre primary remains unaccounted. All the expenditures are shown in main school and entire fee from nursery and KG remains with the greedy school management which is undoubtedly black money. This amount goes up to several crores in some of the schools and when we compare it with actual loss of revenue due to EWS students then we can see that this amount is several fold of the amount spent for EWS students. on the basis of this disclosure i have raised a complaint to Justice Anil Dev Singh committee and the committee written a letter to director education while asking details of enrollment and total amount which school collected from these students. This information has been generated in the response of directorate notification in compliance of order passed by Hon'ble delhi high court in a social jurist PIL for EWS students only.
        some media reports suggests about decrease of seats for general category students which is another myth as the notification for EWS controls the reduction of seats at entry level class and as a result seats has been increased in several schools. Prior to EWS no one had idea about actual number of seats and literally there was no regulation for fixation of seats at entry level class and even directorate of education had no law to do so. As a result there was a gap between declared seats and actual number of seats in the school. Undeclared seats were considered as management seats and it was sold for capitation and the same was not available for general category students. RTI information suggests that the schools reduced seats at entry level class just after ganguly committee recommendation in the year 2007. A large no of admission was undeclared in nursery and the same was reflecting in KG where ganuguly committee recommendation was not applicable
        All the above mentioned details are based on RTI information we have obtained from the directorate of Education Govt. of NCT of Delhi.        
      
     

Monday 8 October 2012

MY LETTER TO CHIEF SECRETARY INFORMING A BIG EDUCATION SCAM



To
The chief secretary
Govt. of NCT of Delhi &
Chief Vigilance officer
I.P.Estate Extension
New Delhi- 110002


Sub- Information about a big education scam and submission of relevant evidences with request to order for investigation.

Dear sir
     Undersign procured some important documents under RTI Act 2005 about a large no of unaided private school and found some institutional fraud is played with the citizen of the city. As a sample case I will request you to have a look at annexed docs relevant to Ryan international Rohini sector 25 where in one document which is based on annual return of school which is meant to disclose revenue and expenditure is showing 43 enrolment in the year 2010-11 and 2011-12 ( annex doc namely chart for two years. This document is prepared by officials of zone-XIII of directorate of education on the basis of class wise enrolment shown by school in their annual return and same has been provided to us in a reply of RTI Application. Now I request to have a look on another document which is undertaking by the principal which shows enrolments 152 in pre school, 180 in pre primary and 362 in class I during the session 2010-11 and enrolments 175 in pre school,150 in pre primary and 180 in class I during academic session 2011-12. It makes very clear that in the year 201-11 a total of 649( 692-43) enrolment was concealed and next year a total of 462 (505-43) enrolment was concealed. If we see only the concealments in two years and that also limited to the entry level class up to class I then also total concealments of 1111 enrolment results in more then five crores of unaccounted money in this one school only.
     For the sake of brevity I am not mentioning here all the cases but in brief request you please to compare the documents from enrolment chart to the individual undertakings where it reveals that N.K. Bagrodia public school Rohini concealed there class Pre school and pre primary in both the academic years, Rockfield school Rohini,GD goenka sector 9 and queen merry school Rohini also did the same as N.K.Bagrodia Rohini. In the case of Bal Bharti Rohini the enrolments of the class pre school and pre primary concealed during year 2010-11 and VSPK International Rohini as well as DAV public school Rohini.
     I have earlier discussed the issue with secretary education and submitted a representation for this also but nothing availed. All these documents are available with the officers of directorate and even they had provided the same to us under reply of RTI application but this huge unaccounted money by playing fraud on the innocent people of this city is sufficient to keep the officers of directorate quite as it is impossible that this kind of fraud can be executed without their consent. I have records for a large no of other schools and if it is needed I assure to provide. This investigation will not need so much of human resource as the documents are already available with directorate. Document related with the enrolment is still available in the format of chart with secretary education and someone can easily detect it within few hours but only will power is needed to protect the citizen and that can be done only by your intervention.
    Therefore your intervention is required for direction of registration of F.I.R. either by CBI or EOW of Delhi Police as proper investigation is needed to crack this fraud which is pinching the pockets of the innocent citizens of the city. Thank You.

With Regards

Khagesh B Jha, Adv.
Chamber No 483, Block II
Delhi High Court New Delhi
Mob- 9350456565